35 Theses on the WASPs
21st November 2026
Consider: the term “WASP” is no older than Digby Baltzell’s sociological treatise The Protestant Establishment, published in 1964. The Stories of John Cheever earned its Pulitzer in 1979. The most influential depiction of the WASPs—Lisa Birnbach’s Official Preppy Handbook—was published in 1980. These books are preoccupied with the prejudices and privileges of the Northeastern elite. Their focus is squarely on mores and manners. This should not surprise. By the time these works were written, the political power of the Establishment had been broken. Their economic preeminence had been eclipsed. Displaced from his central role in the national pageant, at mid-century, the Establishment man was distinguished mostly by his cultural pretensions—pretensions he clung to until J.Crew repackaged them as weekend wear.
Our image of the Eastern Establishment is drawn from this twilight hour. This is not unusual. We tend to remember past cultures as they were just before their close. A living culture is never too sharply defined. Its form is not fixed; its face shifts with mood and circumstance. The expression fixed on a death mask does not alter.
One problem with viewing the Eastern Establishment purely through a cultural lens is that it is easy to take the wrong lessons from their decline. Consider a tweet thread Helen Andrews typed out shortly after the Supreme Court’s 2023 rulings striking down affirmative action. Tweeted she: “The answer to the question why did the WASP elite collapse so rapidly is, literally, changes to undergraduate admissions at a few elite universities.” Andrews predicts that the Court’s decision will eventually erode the cultural coherence of America’s 21st-century elite as conclusively as the meritocratic admissions policies inaugurated by James Conant, Kingman Brewster, and their fellows destroyed the coherence of their 20th-century counterparts. “The lesson of WASPdom’s collapse,” she continues, “is that you can kill an elite by destroying the institutions by which it reproduces itself.”
My friend Rick Brookhiser even wrote a book about it, The Way of the Wasp, which I highly recommend.