Mandatory Usury in One Lesson
1st January 2010
‘You might have less-than-perfect credit and we’re OK with that,” read an October credit-card solicitation from South Dakota-based First Premier Bank. The interest rate, however, will strike some as usurious: 79.9%. That’s a more than eightfold increase from the 9.9% the bank previously collected for a similar card.
Wait, wasn’t Congress supposed to have passed legislation against predatory lending? As a matter of fact, yes. The whopping rate increase is First Premier’s way of complying with the Credit Card Accountability, Responsibility and Disclosure Act of 2009. Among other provisions, that law prohibits fees of more than 25% above a card’s credit limit. First Premier has been offering an account with a $250 limit and annual fees of $256. By law the latter figure must come down to $75. To compensate for the lost $181 in fees, the bank is raising the rate by 70% of $250, or $175, a year.
Markets appear even when you don’t want them to, and even when Congress doesn’t want them to. Clamp down on one part and a compensating bulge appears somewhere else. For some reason legislators never seem able to learn this simple lesson in elementary economics.